Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Christmas vs Hannukah



Jesse Weiner was one of my best friends when I was growing up. He lived next door. Every December we engaged in the same debate—which was better: Christmas or Hanukkah.

We both agreed that a tree trumped a menorah---that was never a sticking point. The sticking point was about gifts. He was guaranteed 8 of them. I had no such guarantee. And the thing is that little kids fundamentally do not care about how much oil was left in the lantern or how many wise men arrived at the stable. Little kids care about toys—and how many they will get. Little kids at holiday time are consumed with anything related to the Toys R Us Catalogue—it’s their bible—not the Pentateuch or the gospel according to Matthew.

But not only was Jesse guaranteed 8 gifts he also did not have to work for them like I did. No one held a lump of coal over his head. There was no psycho fat guy in a velvet suit watching him every minute of the day and night for an entire year waiting to yank his booty from a big bag drawn by a magical sleigh. And Jesse was getting those gifts no matter what the weather brought either. No matter how foggy it was on Hanukkah eve his gift would arrive—Jesse had no concerns about a red nosed reindeer’s ability to navigate. Ruth, his mother, provided all the navigation his gifts needed to get from the top of her closet downstairs to their menorah.

So while yes I had a tree and more holiday songs than Oh Hannukah Oh Hannukah and Dreidel Dreidel Dreidel, I am still not sure Jesse had it all that bad—even though I made him believe he did.

I think the luckiest kids in the world are those who celebrate Chrismakah: candy canes and gimmel, a Christmas tree and a menorah, eight gifts plus whatever you get for Christmas. It’s too awesome to contemplate—unless you want to ruin everything by remembering what the two holidays are supposed to be about—faith, miracles and trust in God.

No comments:

Post a Comment